SteadyHealth.com - Health Topics Forum Index
  Find a Doctor   Ask Experts      Articles      Encyclopedia   Blogs   Tickers    Search  Register    FAQ    Log in 

Which is better: adderall or ritalin?

The time now is 07/19/08 - 11:48
Post new topic Reply to topic
SteadyHealth.com - Health Topics Forum Index -> Drugs & Medications -> Prescription Stimulants
Search forums for:
  
Did you find posts in this topic useful?
Author Message
ayars
Silver Member


Joined: 13 Nov 2000
Posts: 246


Report abuse

PostPosted: 12/05/06 - 00:00    Post subject: Which is better: adderall or ritalin? Vote now! Reply with quote


Hi, Can anyone explain me what is better Adderall or Ritalin? I heard that adderall has less side effects.
Back to top
Did you find this post useful?
halligan
Newbie


Joined: 25 May 2005
Posts: 20


Report abuse

PostPosted: 12/15/06 - 09:02    Post subject: Vote now! Reply with quote


Hi, I have been using Adderall for treatment of ADD for some time. The most important thing is whether you react to certain drug or not. In my experience Adderall has been a little bit more effective than Ritalin. But there are many people who respond positively to Ritalin and not Adderall. It is said that Ritalin’s action abrupt suddenly and Adderall interferes with sleep. . Adderall has a longer period of action than Ritalin, even if you take the long acting Ritalin. The higher the dose of Adderall you take, the longer is the action. Some people take Adderall in the morning and afternoon. For Ritalin suggested time for applying it is the late afternoon or early evening.
Back to top
Did you find this post useful?
Your Ad Here
Upton O'Goode
Silver Member


Joined: 30 Jul 2007
Posts: 174


Report abuse

PostPosted: 08/06/07 - 08:11    Post subject: Vote now! Reply with quote

This is a question that should be explored with a physician who has prescribing experience in your condition and familiarity with your history. If you aren't satisfied with the treatment you are receiving, you have options. Discuss them with your physician and, if necessary, consult other specialists.

All you'll find here are anecdotes about how different drugs worked for different people, none of whom is identical to you. The reason there are so many different medications being prescribed for this condition is that the effectiveness of different drugs, as well as their side-effects, varies profoundly among different individuals, as do the manifestations of ADD itself. As a very broad generalization, amphetamines are generally better for treating adult ADD while methylphenidate is usually better for children. Take that with a large grain of salt.

Personally, I felt no affect from Concerta (a formulation of methylphenidate, similar to Ritalin but with a unique osmotic release mechanism) or Wellbutrin (or bupropion, an antidepressant often used in ADD treatment). Adderall produced very satisfactory results, but I gradually developed a tolerance, and soon the maximum safe dose became somewhat less than adequate.
Back to top
Did you find this post useful?
Upton O'Goode
Silver Member


Joined: 30 Jul 2007
Posts: 174


Report abuse

PostPosted: 09/01/07 - 23:23    Post subject: Vote now! Reply with quote

You are correct. While there are certain things you can do to manipulate the bioavailability of a drug (i.e. enhance absorption or accelerate excretion) you can't deviate more than around 20% from the average half-life. While it is true that you will be found more Adderall circulating in your blood the next day if you take 60 mg the day before than if you took 20, a person who is prescribed 60 mg/d won't notice a longer lasting effect than someone who is prescribed 20 mg/d (assuming both prescriptions are correct) because it takes three times as much to achieve the same effect (due to body mass, tolerance, etc.) in the former.
Back to top
Did you find this post useful?
my2cents
Site Admin


Joined: 12 Apr 2007
Posts: 171


Report abuse

PostPosted: 09/02/07 - 04:00    Post subject: Vote now! Reply with quote

Upton O'Goode wrote:
You are correct. While there are certain things you can do to manipulate the bioavailability of a drug (i.e. enhance absorption or accelerate excretion) you can't deviate more than around 20% from the average half-life. While it is true that you will be found more Adderall circulating in your blood the next day if you take 60 mg the day before than if you took 20, a person who is prescribed 60 mg/d won't notice a longer lasting effect than someone who is prescribed 20 mg/d (assuming both prescriptions are correct) because it takes three times as much to achieve the same effect (due to body mass, tolerance, etc.) in the former.


I must give credit when credit is due. You obviously possess an extensive and thorough degree of knowledge in these particular areas of discussion, and it gives you much credibility. We need more people like you one here. By sharing your knowledge with others, as you are, you are helping others who may be in need of such information. Excellent work, IMHO. Keep those informative posts coming, OK?
Back to top
Did you find this post useful?
Upton O'Goode
Silver Member


Joined: 30 Jul 2007
Posts: 174


Report abuse

PostPosted: 09/02/07 - 11:43    Post subject: Vote now! Reply with quote

Thank you for your kind words. Ordinarily I'd be a little embarrassed by this sort of personal attention, but since this is anonymous... what the heck. Wink

I do try to be accurate in everything I put down here and research anything I'm unclear about, but it's important to restate that nothing that I or anyone else says here should be accepted as authoritative. I say it all the time, but it bears repeating: important health questions should be discussed with a physician. If you don't get the answers you want or have other concerns, get a second opinion.
Back to top
Did you find this post useful?
Guest
Guest






Report abuse

PostPosted: 12/15/07 - 09:54    Post subject: Re: Which is better: adderall or ritalin? Vote now! Reply with quote

ayars wrote:

Hi, Can anyone explain me what is better Adderall or Ritalin? I heard that adderall has less side effects.


In my experience adderall is better. I am 26 years old and I was diagnosed with ADHD as a child. The doctors presecribed ritalin and I was on the medicine for 2 1/2 years. My parents took me off the medicine because of the side effects. I was like a zomby, I was not eating, and I would just sit their in a daze. A few months ago I wanted to be diagnosed again for testing purposes but the doctors placed me back on medicine. This time they prescribed adderall. I like the way I feel on this medicine. I can consintrate better, I can focus on things much better, and I stay on task. I suggest adderall over ritalin. (in my opinion)
Back to top
Did you find this post useful?
Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic Reply to topic
SteadyHealth.com - Health Topics Forum Index -> Drugs & Medications -> Prescription Stimulants All times are GMT - 5 Hours
Page 1 of 1

Related topics:
Which is better:Treadmill or Outdoor Running
Who's better: Valuev or Chagaev?
adderall and alcohol
Side effects of mixing Adderall and Alcohol?
is adderall prescribed for adults as well children
Alcohol While On Adderall?
Adderall hpv
Adderall Effects
mixing medications adderall ambien
Inflamed Sore Mouth after taking Adderall
No periods while on Adderall
slightly confused…on adderall
Could it just be Adderall side effects and not mental problem like my doc thinks?
Suddenly stopped taking Adderall!
Overdosed on adderall, now have stomach problems
Help suicial ADHD 8yo son on ADDERALL
Adderall vs Dexedrine
adult just diagnosed ADD - take adderall or straterra?
Is AdderallXR really good for weightloss?
Scrotum problems... possibly adderall?
reactions of mixing lexapro, adderall and marijuana
Alternatives to Adderall
ritalin cause ejaculation
afib ritalin
Ritalin vc Concerta in children
Going from RITALIN to CONCERTA
mixing ritalin and clonodine
Focalin vs Ritalin
cowden disease ritalin
isn't this too much of ritalin
Warnings related to Concerta And Ritalin
What kind of side effects has Ritalin?
do you know all ritalin side effects
Ritalin and Pregnancy
Divorce Increases Risk of Ritalin Use in Children
ritalin FAQs
Ritalin and stomache pain
ritalin stopped working
withdrawls from ritalin
ritalin problems
Ritalin effectivness in treating ADHD
What should I know about Ritalin?
My Navigator
  • Unanswered posts

  •