SteadyHealth.com - Health Topics Forum Index
  Find a Doctor   Ask Experts      Articles      Encyclopedia   Blogs   Tickers    Search  Register    FAQ    Log in 

May 21, 2006

Best protein supplements for weight training

by SirGan

SteadyHealth.com - Health Topics Forum Index -> Articles archive

Physical performance depends on various muscle functions, including strength. Muscle protein synthesis and breakdown are central in determining both strength and overall function. When a person decides to eat some of the common meal-replacement products such as protein shakes, bars, etc., what is the main reason? The reasons cited for using protein and amino acid supplements include
  • stimulation and maintenance of muscle growth and strength,
  • enhancement of energy utilization
  • Stimulation of the release of growth hormone.
Certainly the food supplement industry gives a lot of reasons to consume their products – claims of increased fat loss, higher energy levels, or better protein availability are several of the more popular claims.
But is there is any real evidence to support the use of these products? This isn't anything so new!
Protein supplements have been very popular in the sport of body building for many years now! The fact is that there were many heated debates about the value of specific sources of protein, and the value of consuming individual amino acids or hydrolyzed proteins over whole proteins.

What are proteins?

Proteins are substances which are made up from Amino Acids. Protein makes up basically everything in human body. In fact the only thing human body has more of than protein is water.
The fact is that proteins are the building block of our whole body - muscles, tissues, hair, nails, etc… It is proven that, if you do not have enough protein in your body you can not build muscle mass, because the body needs to break protein down to amino acids to build muscles. So, the bottom line is that- no matter how much you work out, if you don't have protein, you will not gain muscle mass.
Protein is also necessary to repair and rebuild your muscles.

How much proteins is enough?

There is no doubt that it's true that weight lifters and other athletes need more protein than the rest of people who are not practicing these high0powered sports.
Recent studies are indicating that a 90kg heavy athlete should eat between 120 and 180 grams of protein every day, while a 90kg heavy computer-relate employee can get by quite nicely on only 70 to 90 grams. So, it is reasonable that athletes also need more calories than the rest of us. The typical American eats 50 to 70 percent more protein than necessary and almost all athletes get their daily requirement in what they eat. There is one universal formula- 45 to 55 percent of calories should come from complex carbohydrates, 20 to 35 percent should come from fat, and only 10 to 35 percent from protein.
When too much protein is ingested, the body must eliminate it, resulting in dehydration and calcium loss through the urine.
As an estimate we figure that you should consume between 0.7 - 0.9 grams of protein per pound of body weight. Women have higher body fat than men, so they should be on the lower end of the scale. Here are some examples:
  • 150 pounds = 105 - 135 grams of protein a day
  • 160 pounds = 112 - 144 grams of protein a day
  • 170 pounds = 119 - 153 grams of protein a day
  • 180 pounds = 126 - 162 grams of protein a day
  • 190 pounds = 133 - 171 grams of protein a day
  • 200 pounds = 140 - 180 grams of protein a day
  • 220 pounds = 154 - 198 grams of protein a day
  • 240 pounds = 168 - 216 grams of protein a day
  • 260 pounds = 182 - 234 grams of protein a day

What types of food are filled with proteins?

Protein is found in common foods such as beef, fish, chicken, milk, eggs and cheese. Eating a diet rich in these foods is a good way to get protein. Unfortunately it can also be a good way to increase a lot of other things like fats and sugars, which most of us don’t want in our bodies!
 
Food
Amount of Protein
3 oz. broiled ground beef
21 grams
3 oz. roasted ham
18 grams
3 oz. veal -broiled
23 grams
3.5 oz. roasted chicken
27 grams
3.5 oz. baked/roasted salmon
27 grams
3.5 oz. tuna canned in water
28 grams
1 beef frankfurter
6 grams
1 oz. sliced ham
5 grams
1 large boiled egg
6 grams
1 cup of Milk
8 grams

What are protein supplements?

Protein supplements are substances made in laboratories for replacing meals and daily needs for proteins. They come in different shapes such as pills, powders, shakes, bars…
The truth is that, several researches done in the past have proven that there is no biological advantage in consuming individual amino acids. Some people take them because the claim is that they are absorbed more quickly and better. However, this isn't true! The body’s digestive system was primary designed to consume and utilize proteins in whole foods, and it has plenty of enzymes to break down proteins for the needs of the body.
Not all protein supplements are the same!
Protein supplements can be made from a few different source of protein. These include
  • milk protein,
  • egg protein,
  • Soy protein.
The better a protein is absorbed by the body the higher the Biological Value the protein is said to have.

Biological value of proteins

This test measures the amount of protein retained in the human body per gram of protein absorbed. This measure started out as a percentage - with a whole egg being at the top of the chart - 100% protein absorbed. Latest discoveries have proven that the whey is a better source of protein than an egg - so it actually scores higher than 100. So, today BV is a number which lets you compare different types of protein. Here is the BV of some common foods:
Protein
BV
Whey isolate
110-159
Whey concentrate
104
Whole egg
100
Cow's milk
91
Egg white
88
Fish
83
Beef
80
Chicken
79
Casein
77
Soy
74
Rice
59
Wheat
54
Beans
49

When is the best time to take a protein supplement?

Of course, this depends on the type of diet and when you are eating foods rich in protein. Here are a few points when it is best to take a protein supplement:
  • Right after a workout - this is when your body goes into a stage of recovery and growth. Having the amino acids that make up the protein is primary goal at this point.
  • First thing in the morning - because your body has just gone though 8 hours (or however long you sleep for) of not having food - so the protein levels are way down.
  • Before you go to sleep - this helps prevent the protein breakdown that naturally occurs when we sleep. If you are not trying to build muscle mass then this protein breakdown is fine. But if you are working out - you want to try to minimize any losses you suffer when you sleep and your protein metabolism slows down.

Are protein supplements dangerous?

A little extra protein for most people won't do much harm, so feel free to have a protein bar now and then. But you can definitely overdose your self and that’s why you should be very careful. It is proven that a protein overload can cause
  • stomach trouble
  • dehydration
  • gout
  • calcium loss
  • Damage to the liver and kidneys.
Many people are confused because they don’t know could these proteins make them fat? Well, the answer is No. They can in fact help you if you are on a diet. You see the amino acids in protein may help keep your blood sugar levels stabile. This is important because it keeps you feeling good all day and stops your craving for food that occurs when your blood sugar level drops. In addition, if you are dieting, getting 17 grams of protein from a protein shake that has only 90 calories is better than getting your protein from a big meal which may have hundreds of calories.

Most common protein supplements, pros and cons

  • Protein Bars and Shakes
    When these foods are supplemental to the diet, high energy protein bars and shakes can do a good job of adding body weight in the form of easy to consume, highly dense calories, especially for the person that want to gain weight! If you want to loose weight and you consume these products as a substitute for a real meal- they have much less value.

    Meal replacements are a poor, expensive substitute for real foods, because they don’t contain the natural, beneficial substances present in real food. But no one can tell anything against the fact that that they are really a convenient source of energy. If your choice is to eat a typical fast food meal or a meal replacement shake- you are probably better off choosing the meal replacement! 
  • Meal replacement powders
    The first thing you need to have in a protein powder is great taste! What is the purpose of these male replacement powders? Well, the purpose of meal replacement powders is to eliminate the time-consuming and inconvenient preparing a full-fledged meal. It's important that your meal replacement offers a proper balance of calories from protein, carbohydrates, dietary fiber, and all the essential vitamins and minerals your body requires.

    Essentially, protein powder supplements provide a quick fix of high quality protein without the fat and carbohydrates, which is perfect for post-workout recuperation or for a quick snack before going to bed. Ultra Met Champion Nutrition is definitely the most common and a very delicious new dietary supplement. The powder is loaded with high quality protein and the essential nutrients that scientifically replace a traditional meal, with only a few seconds of preparation. Meal replacement powders are the perfect solution for busy men who don't always have access to a kitchen. Fueling up on meal replacements can also help minimize your intake of greasy fast foods.
  • Amino Acids as growth-hormone-releasers
    Arginine, ornithine and lysine are amino acids, which are promoted as 'growth hormone releasers'. Experts suggest that these amino acids will increase muscle growth while stimulating breakdown of body fat. The proven fact is that these amino acids Arginine, ornithine and lysine are known to increase levels of human growth hormone when injected into the bloodstream at high doses. Whether there's any effect when these substances are given by mouth is far more controversial.
COMMENTS
Readers posted 0 comments for this article
View comments
Write your comment
ARTICLE RATING


[ 9 voters ]

Rate this article:

bad
average
good
very good
excellent

SYNDICATE FEED






    Article sources
    • www.ahealthyme.com
    • www.dietsurf.com
    • www.askmen.com