My heart beat was caused by fluid in my ear. An Osteopath dr manipulated bones in my head so the fluid in my ear would drain better. The Swellen canal (in my ear) is completly gone and the swoshing gone. The heart beat is 75% gone and not near as loud or often but some times it gets really loud when I turn my head a certan way which makes me think I have a weak artery in there. Sorry for all the bad spelling :-( good luck to all of you.