Couldn't find what you looking for?

TRY OUR SEARCH!

Would them being stored a sealed zip-lock bag make a difference in your answer?

Loading...

Yes.

no.

Should I be ashamed?
Reply

Loading...

No I would not get Marshmallows from 2004, not even if I were pour. Not in a box with a fox....
Reply

Loading...

if they're still spongy they should be okay. if you throw one against the wall and it crumbles, probably not a good thing.
Reply

Loading...

if you melt it does it still make smores?


if yes: then i don't see what the problem is.

if no: probably should pass.
Reply

Loading...

if there's nothing blue on them, eat them.
Reply

Loading...

and just WTH is THAT supposed to mean :-x
Reply

Loading...

Should I be ashamed?
No! You're in good company! They were part of my hot choco kit from a friend last Christmas. And they're fine once the hot chocolate melts them a little. 8)
Reply

Loading...

If you melt it, it would make a mess.

If you don't roast them, marshmellows aren't worth eating, period.
Reply

Loading...

Marshmallows, no. Peeps, yes.
Reply

Loading...

Technically I'm drinking them since they've melted into my choco.
Reply

Loading...

No! But I'd eat a peep from 2004. I know, that's f ed up. :-|
Reply

Loading...

No.

My experience with old marshmellows has always been bad.
Reply

Loading...