Browse
Health Pages
Categories
Can exercise alone make you lose significant amounts of weight? The answer, it turns out, is "no". While just dieting can indeed get you there, you still need physical activity to not just lose weight, but do it the healthy way.

Exercise — or, more generally, physical activity — is essential for good health. People who move around regularly and in a variety of ways are more likely to have healthy lungs, hearts, muscles, and bones. Being active reduces your risk of cancer, hypertension, high cholesterol, type 2 diabetes, stress, and dysfunctional sleep.  

There are plenty of reasons to work out regularly or get your physical activity in in other ways, then, and almost no reasons to choose a sedentary lifestyle. Even people with physical or health limitations can almost always find safe ways to be active with their doctor's advice. Is exercise also essential for people who want to lose weight, though? That's certainly a message we receive loudly and clearly, but it may not be as true as you think. 

Just what role does physical activity play in weight loss? Let's take a closer look!

Can you really lose weight by exercising alone?

Yes. But not much, research has shown. 

One study that mainly focused on obese people found that:

  • Increasing the number of steps a person takes every day with the help of a pedometer — from less than 5,000 steps to more than 8,000 — helps them adopt a more physically active lifestyle, and can be quite motivating. Just walking around a  bit more was shown to only enable very modest weight loss, however, to the tune of up to one kilo (just over two pounds). This kind of thing isn't going to cut it for folks who want to lose serious amounts of weight.
  • Current guidelines recommend that adults engage in physical activity at least 150 to 300 minutes a week to reap significant health benefits. People who took part in aerobic exercise programs to get them halfway to this point lost about two kilos on average (just under five pounds). It is possible to lose more weight by engaging in more aerobic exercise, but not much more. 
  • Folks who do resistance training only aren't likely to lose any weight at all, meanwhile. 
  • Combining aerobic exercise with resistance training offers health benefits, but people taking this approach aren't going to lose more weight than those who only engage in aerobic work outs — somewhere between zero and two kilos, research showed. Those who want to lose more weight through this approach would have to be working out almost constantly. 
So, exercise alone isn't going to make you lose significant amounts of weight — neither 10 kilos nor 40 — but that doesn't mean it doesn't play a huge role in your new healthy lifestyle. People with high levels of physical activity will get stronger, work on reducing visceral fat (around the organs), lower their cholesterol levels, and improve their glucose metabolism. Physical activity is a key part of a sustainable weight loss program, but it won't get you where you want to be on its own. 

Combine well-thought out exercise routines with a restricted-calorie diet, on the other hand, and you'll soon be making great strides towards scale victories. The same study we looked at earlier confirmed that an approach in which you exercise regularly while also maintaining a calorie deficit is the most successful approach to weight loss. To maintain your new weight after you've already hit your goal, however, physical activity proved to be essential. 

Can you lose weight through diet alone?

There is no doubt about this one. The answer is an unequivocal "yes". If you burn more calories than you consume, to the tune of 500 to 600 a day, you will lose about half a kilo to a kilo (or one to two pounds) a week. Depending on your current body mass index and lifestyle, you may be able to cut even more — but discuss this with your doctor first. 

The science of weight loss is quite simple, in that it only takes a consistent and fairly significant calorie deficit to lose weight. People who are disciplined enough to, for instance, survive on 900 calories worth of pizza and donuts without being overtaken by food cravings caused by a lack of protein, are still going to drop pounds. It just won't do their health much good. 

Sustainable and healthy weight loss should be the goal, and that means including fruits and vegetables (at least five portions), nice starchy carbs, healthy fats, and enough protein in your diet. Healthy weight loss almost always requires reexamining our diet rather than simply eating less of what we were already getting. Once you start keeping track, chances are that you'll discover you're chronically low on certain vitamins and minerals. A weight loss plan can change all that. 

Diet and exercise: A combo made in heaven 

A healthy low-calorie diet is going to be the backbone of your weight loss, while increased physical activity plays an important but relatively minor role in the dropping numbers on the scale. Exercise will, meanwhile, offer things diet alone never will, making you stronger and fitter. It's true — just eating less and making healthier choices, or just adding more workouts and other kinds of physical activity to your life are both excellent steps. It's when you bring the two together that you really start achieving your goal of not just a slimmer life, but a healthier and more energetic one. 

Sources & Links

Post a comment