Why haven't there been other treatment options for hydrocephalus or indeed new drugs given to us as patients? We have had to endure shunt systems which are a century-old system, which clog and fail and give us excruciating headaches when they fail. If the doctors and scientists were so smart, they would have invented something better than a tube which breaks, clogs and malfunctions or the alternative to drill another hole (in the third ventricle),
As I said to my neurosurgeon, you can cut us open and drill into us but you can't give us proper pain relief for the in-between times or post-surgery when there might be adhesions or the like. Sort of like getting your tyres balanced, then whoops, we're sorry, we only managed to re-tighten two of the four wheel nuts, so your tyre might come off at some stage. Surely there must be something we can do.
Hi.
Hydrocephalus, characterized by the excessive accumulation of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) in the brain, has historically been a challenging condition to treat.
You're correct that ventriculoperitoneal (VP) shunts, which divert excess CSF from the brain to the abdominal cavity, have been the mainstay of treatment for many decades. And while they have certainly helped many individuals, shunt systems are indeed prone to complications, including blockage, malfunction, and infection.
Several factors have contributed to the slow development of alternative treatments:
-
Complexity of the Brain: The brain is one of the most complex organs in the body. Interventions carry the risk of damage, infection, and other complications.
-
Variability of the Disease: Hydrocephalus can have multiple causes, including congenital factors, trauma, tumors, and infections, which can make a one-size-fits-all treatment difficult.
-
Safety Concerns: As with any new treatment, there are potential risks and unintended side effects. For example, the introduction of a new drug would require extensive testing to ensure it doesn't adversely affect brain function.
-
Research and Development Costs: Developing new treatments, especially drugs, can be extremely costly and time-consuming.
That said, there are some alternative treatments and ongoing research into improving care for hydrocephalus:
-
Endoscopic Third Ventriculostomy (ETV): This is a surgical procedure where a hole is made in the bottom of the third ventricle, allowing CSF to bypass obstructions and flow into the subarachnoid space. It can be an alternative to shunting in some cases.
-
ETV with Choroid Plexus Cauterization (CPC): This newer procedure combines ETV with the cauterization of the choroid plexus, the tissue that produces CSF. By reducing CSF production, it may reduce the need for shunting in some individuals, especially infants.
-
Drug Therapies: There has been some research into drugs that can reduce the production of CSF or increase its reabsorption. However, no drug has been identified yet that is effective without significant side effects.
-
Telemetry-Enhanced Shunts: Some newer shunt systems are being equipped with telemetry capabilities, allowing doctors to remotely monitor and adjust shunt settings.
-
Bioengineering Solutions: Researchers are also investigating bioengineered solutions to improve shunt performance, reduce the risk of clogging, and minimize tissue reactions.